Visit TV Watch Online:

Thursday, March 3, 2011

Idol-Talk: Season 10 Top 24 (Top 12 Girls)

American Idol 10: Top 24 (Top 12 Girls)
Air Date: Wednesday, March 2, 2011 [8-9:30pm]

Theme: Sing Whatever You Want

Source: Poptower.com
Yesterday, I wondered if this new stage would be used for the rest of the season or just for the semifinals. And, as if he read my question, Ryan Seacrest announced at the top of show Wednesday night that it would indeed be the stage used for the duration of the season.

The guys were up first on Tuesday, and now the girls are up for America's vote.

1. Ta-Tynisa Wilson - Rihanna's "Only Girl (In the World)"
During the start, it felt to me like her voice and the music were not in sync with each other. Throughout, I heard some flat notes, and she wasn't able to pull off the low notes. The song (which was totally the wrong choice) made that apparent.

On a separate note, why is there a dash in her name all of a sudden? I don't remember that being there in earlier rounds.

2. Naima Adedapo - "Summertime"
Why did she have to sing the most iconic song on American Idol (with Fantasia providing what was inarguably the best performance in the history of the show) for her first big performance of the season? There will always be comparisons. She didn't match up, and the vocals weren't perfect. But that doesn't mean this performance was a dud; far from it: She does know how to belt out those power notes.

3. Kendra Chantelle - Christina Aguilera's "Impossible"
To me, she was more in between tonight. I wasn't blown away, but neither was it terrible either. As Randy said, there were some sharp notes. But she ended on a positive note, with the power voice coming through.

4. Rachel Zevita - Fiona Apple's "Criminal"
She should not have made the Top 24, so it's no surprise that she is still terrible and hasn't improved. Her voice was all over the place. She relied more on theatrics, which tried to mask the voice.

5. Karen Rodriguez - Mariah Carey's "Hero"
When I realized what song it was, I thought she shouldn't do such a well known and overdone song for her first time. But what went in her favor was the switch to Spanish. The English parts were just like the original, but the Spanish improved it. Regardless, she has a powerful voice that could take her far.

6. Lauren Turner - Etta James' "Seven Day Fool"
I wasn't liking it at first, because it felt amateurish and the run was all over the place. But she picked it up in the second half, showing more personality and mood. There was some rasp in her voice at one point, which helped the performance, I thought.

7. Ashthon Jones - Monica's "Love Over Me"
I wasn't really that in love with this performance. The song choice wasn't the best for her - the root of my feelings here. There were some great notes at the end, but that can carry over to the whole set with the right song. But she's no doubt talented, and has a chance of moving forward.

8. Julie Zorrilla - Kelly Clarkson's "Breakaway"
She has a weak voice to begin with, and add to that the fact that it's a Kelly Clarkson song - she's a goner. If Kelly's a 100, then Julie's version was a 10. Her voice was flat throughout, and she couldn't project it that loud either.

9. Haley Reinhart - Alicia Keys' "Fallin"
A song like this is almost untouchable, because it's hard to do it justice. She pales in comparison with Alicia Keys. Her voice was a little shaky at times. I don't remember if she was good before, but this is not the way to make it.

10. Thia Megia - "Out Here On My Own" from Fame
She started off a capella, which drew me in right away. I thought at some point the song would pick up more (maybe due to my unfamiliarity with the song), but when it didn't, I was still impressed. She has great control over her voice, knowing when to be restrained.

11. Lauren Alaina - Reba McEntire's "Turn On the Radio"
She started to go downhill a bit the past couple of episodes, but this performance brought her back on top. She fused country with rock effortlessly. During her audition, I was reminded of Kelly Clarkson, and I'm seeing that again. Out of all the audition stops, she was the obvious favorite. And now that she's back on top, my hope is that she can remain excellent while not being too perfect each and every time during these first couple weeks. The reason why I say this is because I don't want her to go the way of Crystal Bowersox. Crystal started out as the favorite, but once she stumbled about halfway through, she was never able to regain ground in the voting, and Lee's improvements cause him to soar past her for the win.

12. Pia Toscano - The Pretenders' "I'll Stand By You"
She was good, but I don't think a standing ovation by the judges was necessary. For most of the song, I didn't hear anything that stood out from other renditions. What saved her, though, was the end, causing the cheers from the audience and judges.

Favorite Performances: Lauren Alaina / Thia Megia

My Votes: Lauren Alaina - 20 votes

Top 10 Predictions (5 will advance):
Lauren Alaina
Thia Megia
Pia Toscano
Naima Adedapo
Ashthon Jones

Lauren, Thia and Pia are the only ones that I believe have a guarantee to get in the Top 10+. After that, it's a little harder to pick two more spots. I ultimately went with Naima and Ashthon, based on my own comments, what the judges said, and audience reaction. But Karen Rodriguez or Lauren Turner may get in as well.

Based on both performance nights, American will vote through five guys and five girls into the finals. Then the judges will have their Wild Card picks. The rumor that's been around for a while is that there will ultimately be a Top 13, with each judge choosing one contestant. If that is the case, I will add a few more names to my prediction lists that may make the Top 10+, whether by America's vote or chosen by the judges. I will just go ahead and put out these names: Robbie Rosen (even though he was just okay this week, he can do better), Karen Rodriguez, and Lauren Turner. Who knows, maybe Brett Loewenstern or Kendra Chantelle or someone else may make it.

Tonight, we have a two hour results show, where we will find out who has made it into the Top 10. Then, the judges will reportedly make their Wild Card picks, though one rumor floating around is that next week will be devoted to the Wild Card. And Jennifer Lopez will debut the music video for her new single, "On the Floor." See ya then...

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Idol-Talk: Season 10 Top 24 (Top 12 Boys)


American Idol 10: Top 24 (Top 12 Boys)
Air Date: Tuesday, March 1, 2011 [8-9:30pm]

Theme: Sing Whatever You Want

The semifinals have begun...and are almost over. In years' past, this round has always been around three weeks, but the format has changed as one of the ways to revitalize the show. The top 12 guys performed last night, and the theme was...there was no theme. They could sing whatever they wanted.


This round usually has a smaller stage and audience seating, but they've expanded it all, making it look closer to the regular stage we see for the Top 12. I don't know if this will be the same stage used for the rest of the season or not, because why would they build all of this just for one week? I guess we'll just have to wait and see.

Ryan Seacrest gave Steven Tyler a bleep sign that is the American Idol logo on a stick so that he can cover his mouth with it if he's going to swear. I don't think it always worked.

I couldn't get a complete picture of the band arrangement, but I saw at least part of the band on (our) left side of the stage. The other edge of the stage housed the rest of the singers, where they sat and watched all the performances.

Besides the normal phone and text voting, Idol has added online voting at AmericanIdol.com (through Facebook).

1. Clint Jun Gamboa - Stevie Wonder's "Superstition": The first half was just okay, and I thought that would carry throughout, but once he hit the high notes, he pushed his energy fully into the performance and gave it his all.

2. Jovany Barreto - Edwin McCain's "I'll Be": I'm glad Randy Jackson told the truth - It was very karaoke-like. A few seconds in when I realized what song it was, I thought - Uh oh. I was bored for most of the song. Some great notes at the end, but overall very forgettable.

3. Jordan Dorsey - Usher's "OMG":He was in trouble right from the start. I think the first few lines were supposed to be low notes, but he couldn't make them work, so they came out very quiet. With the dancing, he relied too much on sex appeal, which affected his vocals. The song has very stacatto notes, so I couldn't tell anything about his voice from this.

4. Tim Halperin - Rob Thomas' "Streetcorner Symphony (Come On Over)": I might have to remove the karaoke label from Jovany and stick it on Tim, because this performance was the epitome of karaoke. I started to become a fan of his the last couple of episodes or so, but this did nothing to help him. He can do better, but I don't know if he'll be around to do so.

5. Brett Loewenstern - The Doors' "Light My Fire": In earlier rounds, he's had both good performances and some pretty average ones. This one was more on the average side. His voice was off at the start, better at the end. He's been heavily featured, so he has a chance of making it.

6. James Durbin - Judas Priest's "You Got Another Thing Comin'": He's always had comparisons to Adam Lambert, but hasn't matched up to him before now. This rock song could have been his downfall, but I was pleasantly surprised by how well he tackled this song. I wonder if this is the musical route he should take. Also, I'm glad he didn't overdo the high notes.

7. Robbie Rosen - Sarah McLachlan's "Arms of An Angel": He has been my favorite leading up to this week. There were moments when I heard some beautiful notes, but I heard a lot of pitch problems and one or two strained notes as well. I expect better from him, because he can do a lot better.

8. Scotty McCreery - John Michael Montgomery's "Letters from Home": I'm glad he chose a song that fit his music style. I've never been a fan of his, and while his voice wasn't that bad, I wasn't blown away. He might make it since he's the lone country singer, but he still needs to step it up.

9. Stefano Langone - Bruno Mars' "Just the Way You Are": There seems to be a pattern tonight, where many start out average then improve by the end. For Stefano, the start was not good, but I loved the last half (save for the cringe-worthy high note). Having said that, did this sound any different than the original?

10. Paul McDonald - Rod Stewart's "Maggie Mae": If I'm not mistaken, they only featured him last week. I wasn't on board then and I'm still not completely a fan. Maybe I still need to warm up to him. I hear a good voice, but I just don't know what to think yet.

11. Jacob Lusk - "A House is Not a Home": He can definitely sing, there's no doubt about that. And I'm sure he'll make it. But I'm trying to look ahead, and I don't see him making it big. He's talented, but that doesn't always equal record sales.

12. Casey Abrams - "I Put a Spell on You": Based on that performance, I wouldn't have known he was ill (for the most part). He brought his energy and put everything into that song. The last notes were all over the place, but it still kind of fit in with it all.

We knew that both Steven and Jennifer Lopez were going to be nicer than Simon Cowell, but I thought last night they were way too soft on the contestants. Randy Jackson was the only one on the panel that really told the truth and gave honest feedback. I agreed with Randy most of the time, surprisingly.

Favorite Performances: James Durbin / Casey Abrams

My Votes: James Durbin - 20 votes
     [I decided not to vote online; I figured that I could vote by phone faster than doing it online. Maybe later on I'll include online voting as well]

Top 12 Predictions (5 will advance):
James Durbin
Casey Abrams
Paul McDonald
Scotty McCreery
Jacob Lusk

When I first wrote down a list of those who have a chance of making it into the Top 12, I included Brett and Robbie as well. I have logical reasons why those two will stay in (just read my comments on them above), but I ultimately cut them when you look at those who stepped it up and provided the best performances of the night. That leads you to the list of five names above. There's always the judges Wild Card picks, so even if some are eliminated, there's always the chance that the judges will keep them.

Instead of having a separate page on the main T.W.O. site for the links to the American Idol performances on iTunes, I was planning on just linking to them here in my Idol-Talk blogs. But it looks like there's nothing up on iTunes yet. If they become available, I will update this entry with the links.

Now that the guys have performed, the Top 12 girls will take to the stage tonight (8-9:30pm). See ya then...

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Oscars: My Predictions vs. Winners

The 83rd Annual Academy Awards were held this past Sunday, and I seem to be on a bit of a roll lately.  First, I only miss four categories at the Golden Globes last month (84% correct).  And surprisingly, that success rolled over to this week, when I only missed five, resulting in 79% correct.

Here's the list of winners along with my predictions:

Best Picture:
The King's Speech
My Prediction:
The Social Network (-)

Best Actor:
Colin Firth, The King's Speech
My Prediction:
Colin Firth, The King's Speech (+)

Best Supporting Actor:
Christian Bale, The Fighter
My Prediction:
Christian Bale, The Fighter (+)

Best Actress:
Natalie Portman, Black Swan
My Prediction:
Natalie Portman, Black Swan (+)

Best Supporting Actress:
Melissa Leo, The Fighter
My Prediction:
Melissa Leo, The Fighter (+)

Best Animated Film:
Toy Story 3
My Prediction:
Toy Story 3 (+)

Best Art Direction:
Alice in Wonderland
My Prediction:
Alice in Wonderland (+)

Best Cinematography:
Inception
My Prediction:
True Grit (-)

Best Costume Design:
Alice in Wonderland
My Prediction:
Alice in Wonderland (+)

Best Director:
Tom Hooper, The King's Speech
My Prediction:
David Fincher, The Social Network (-)

Best Documentary:
Inside Job
My Prediction:
Inside Job (+)

Best Documentary Short:
Strangers No More
My Prediction:
Strangers No More (+)

Best Editing:
The Social Network
My Prediction:
The Social Network (+)

Best Foreign Language Film:
In a Better World (Denmark)
My Prediction:
In a Better World (Denmark) (+)

Best Makeup:
The Wolfman
My Prediction:
The Wolfman (+)

Best Score:
The Social Network, Trent Reznor & Atticus Ross
My Prediction:
The Social Network, Trent Reznor & Atticus Ross (+)

Best Song:
"We Belong Together," Toy Story 3
My Prediction:
"We Belong Together," Toy Story 3 (+)

Best Animated Short:
The Lost Thing
My Prediction:
Day & Night (-)

Best Live-Action Short:
God of Love
My Prediction:
Na Wewe (-)

Best Sound Editing:
Inception
My Prediction:
Inception (+)

Best Sound Mixing:
Inception
My Prediction:
Inception (+)

Best Visual Effects:
Inception
My Prediction:
Inception (+)

Best Original Screenplay:
The King's Speech, David Seidler
My Prediction:
The King's Speech, David Seidler (+)

Best Adapted Screenplay:
The Social Network, Aaron Sorkin
My Prediction:
The Social Network, Aaron Sorkin (+)

I got 19 of the 24 categories correct, missing only five (79% correct).

I was trying to think of why I'm doing better this year with my predictions.  And while I always have looked at what others are saying, I have done a lot more research this year, not only looking at what other websites are predicting, but thinking about what is in each film that could warrant a win, watching clips from some of the smaller categories (Best Animated Short, Best Live-Action Short), reading summaries of the documentaries, and listening to the nominated songs.  I usually do a lot of that already, but I focused more and analyzed the environment closer than I may usually have done. Next stop - the Emmy's!

You can view the full list of nominees, winners, and my predictions on T.W.O.'s Oscars page.

Sunday, February 27, 2011

T.W.O: Oscar Predictions

Tonight ABC will air the 83rd Annual Academy Awards, beginning at 8:30pm ET/5:30pm PT. Last night, I finalized my Oscar predictions for all 24 categories. Below are my predictions, and check out T.W.O.'s Oscars page for a full list of all the nominees.

Source: gaelick.com
T.W.O.'s Oscar Predictions:

Best Picture:
The Social Network

Best Actor:
Colin Firth, The King's Speech

Best Supporting Actor:
Christian Bale, The Fighter

Best Actress:
Natalie Portman, Black Swan

Best Supporting Actress:
Melissa Leo, The Fighter

Best Animated Film:
Toy Story 3

Best Art Direction:
Alice in Wonderland

Best Cinematography:
True Grit

Best Costume Design:
Alice in Wonderland

Best Director:
David Fincher, The Social Network

Best Documentary:
Inside Job

Best Documentary Short:
Strangers No More

Best Editing:
The Social Network

Best Foreign Language Film:
In a Better World (Denmark)

Best Makeup:
The Wolfman

Best Score:
The Social Network, Trent Reznor & Atticus Ross

Best Song:
"We Belong Together," Toy Story 3

Best Animated Short:
Day & Night

Best Live-Action Short:
Na Wewe

Best Sound Editing:
Inception

Best Sound Mixing:
Inception

Best Visual Effects:
Inception

Best Original Screenplay:
The King's Speech, David Seidler

Best Adapted Screenplay:
The Social Network, Aaron Sorkin

I decided to do a little research into the Best Picture category and see which of this year's nominated films has the best chance to win. For this research, I looked at the Golden Globe Best Picture (Drama and Musical/Comedy) winners and Oscar Best Picture winners of the last ten years (2001-2010). Exactly half of the Oscar winners also won in the same category for the Golden Globes. The reason why I did this was because I wanted to see if The Social Network had a chance of winning, since it won the Globe last month. Even though momentum at the moment is with The King's Speech, based on recent history, Network has a 50% chance of winning.

Next, I focused exclusively on the Oscar winners; more specifically, I looked at the content and topics of these films; again, this was to see which could come out on top between The Social Network and The King's Speech. The Academy tends to prefer movies along the lines of Speech, which everyone is predicting will win (besides the fact that it also won some important awards recently).

For the most part, I do base my prediction decisions on who has the best chance at winning, though once in a while my personal picks override it. Last year, I chose Avatar over The Hurt Locker for Best Picture, even though it was pretty obvious that the Academy would prefer the Iraq war film over the mega blockbuster.

If I was being smart here, I would obviously choose Speech. However, my personal pick is once again overriding it. It's probably because, of the two, I've only seen Network. If this was a perfect world, the race would be between Network and Toy Story 3 (the two best movies of 2010), but that's not feasible when you look at what the voting members go for. So, while my Best Picture prediction isn't exactly logical, I'm going to be laughing (well, maybe not; I'll probably be in shock) if Network does indeed win. And if Speech wins, as it most likely will, I'll still be fine with the choice.

At last month's Golden Globe Awards, I got 84% of my predictions correct (only missing four), which I'm sure is the best I have ever done at the three major award shows (Emmys, Globes, Oscars); I usually never get above 50%. I hope my luck there will drag over to tonight's awards and be at least above 50%.

Once the winners have been announced, I will be writing up a follow-up entry comparing my predictions to the eventual winners.

Saturday, February 26, 2011

American Idol Scorecards - Top 24

For those of you who like to keep track of what songs the contestants sing and how well they perform, I am putting online American Idol Scorecards. I first started using scorecards back in season 4 when the American Idol Magazine began. After the magazine ended, I created my own, in a similar fashion to the ones found in the mag, altering them slightly to fit my preference. Over the years, I have continued to make changes to them to suit what I want to use them for.

I'm not sure how many other people do this as well, but I thought I would put online the scorecards I created for anyone to download, print, and use as they wish:



The above links take you to Google Docs. I suggest downloading them in their original file so as to make sure the format remains the same (usually by clicking on 'File' and 'Download original'); you will know the formatting is correct if you see the headings (Vocal Ability, Song Choice, etc) on their sides In a vertical fashion.

There is room for you to write in the contestant's names, song titles, comments, and give each performance a rating based on four categories (the point system in the document is what I began using last year; change them as you see fit). At the bottom, you will see space to write in the theme, who you vote for and how much, your predictions, and who ends up either advancing or getting eliminated.

So far, I only have the scorecards up for the Top 24 (next week). Let me know if you want me to continue putting these online and I will.

Idol-Talk: Season 10 - Top 24 Chosen

American Idol 10: Top 24 Chosen
Air Date: Thursday, February 24, 2011 [8-10pm]

Source: mjsbigblog.com
This past Wednesday, the judges began winnowing the field down to the Top 24 semifinalists that will compete for our votes next week. Thursday's episode concluded this process with a two(!) hour show. Did anyone else feel like that was way too long? To Idol's credit, they did make sure to feature every single semifinalist equally instead of brushing over some of the singers who weren't featured as much in previous rounds, but couldn't they still have done that in a shorter period of time? I was getting restless after a while. Oh well...

Wednesday's show ended on a "dramatic" cliffhanger: Jennifer Lopez broke down crying after eliminating Chris Medina. And to bring on the drama even more, Thursday's show began with Ryan Seacrest (on voice over) saying, "Will Jennifer find the strength to go on?" We saw shots of what looked like producers (including EP Nigel Lythgoe) surrounding her. After taking a short break, she was ready to continue on.

Five of the Top 24 (announced Wednesday):

  • Naima Adedapo
  • Clint Jun Gamboa
  • Hayley Reinhart
  • Paul McDonald
  • Ashthon Jones
The Rest of the Top 24 (announced Thursday):
  • Karen Rodriguez
  • Robbie Rosen - "Sorry Seems to Be the Hardest Word"
  • Tatynisa Wilson: If that final performance is anything to go by, she won't be around much longer.
  • Tim Halperin
  • Julie Zorrilla: As she leaves, Lady Gaga's new song, "Born This Way," plays over the shot. I have had that song stuck in my head ever since I first heard it on the Friday before the Grammy's; every time it's out of my head, the next thing I know I'm hearing it play on TV again and again. At least it's a song that I like, right?
  • Scotty McCreery: He definitely improved with that final song, but I really haven't heard anything new that we haven't heard from him before. What I mean is, the range of his voice isn't that different from song to song. I don't think he is Top 24 material.
  • Jovany Barreto
  • Lauren Turner
  • Rachael Zevita - Lady Gaga's "Speechless": I could barely recognize that it was that song at first. She says to the judges something along the lines of, "I don't know what you want me to do." That isn't the smartest thing to say. She's basically saying, "Tell me what I should sing and sound like, because I don't know what my music style is." If she doesn't know that already (or if she doesn't figure it out pretty soon), she may be doomed.
  • Kendra Chantelle: She sings her audition song, which she shouldn't have done. I have already criticized others during Hollywood Week for relying on their first song, because it doesn't let us or the judges know the range that they have. She's basically trying to take the easy way into the Top 24.
  • Jordan Dorsey
  • Lauren Alaina - "Unchained Melody": I saw an improvement with this final song. I hope, though, she is able to really head back to the top in upcoming rounds, or else she might go the way of last year's Katie Stevens, who started out as one of the favorites from the auditions then fizzled out.
  • Stefano Langone
  • Jacob Lusk - "A Song For You": There were some off moments during the song.
  • Pia Toscano
  • James Durbin - "A Change is Gonna Come": The high notes were certainly an improvement upon Hollywood Week. However, since he already has comparisons to Adam Lambert, why sing a song that Adam did back in season 8 on the show?
  • Casey Abrams: I got a very jazz and bluesy vibe from this performance. I'm trying to look forward in the competition and see what could take him to the end, and I don't think the kind of style he featured here will do that for him. But no matter, he did a great job nonetheless.
  • Thia Megia - Josh Groban's "You Raise Me Up": I found this to be a very refreshing rendition of such an overdone song, because I'm so used to people singing it who have similar voices to Groban.
    • Thia and Jessica Cunningham were the final two girls and went into the hangar together to face the judges verdict. Only one would make it in, and Thia rightly got that spot.
  • Brett Loewenstern: Jacee Badeaux, Brett and Colton Dixon were not only the final three guys, but the very final contestants to find out their fate. Only one out of the three would make it in. Brett must have miscounted, because he thought there were two spots; fortunately, it went in his favor.
    • While I wouldn't have been surprised if the judges went soft and let Jacee in as well, they did the right thing, because he wasn't ready yet; Jacee could very well have been swallowed up in the competition in the live rounds.
    • For his final performance, Colton chose a song by Daughtry. Isn't this the second time that he has taken on a Daughtry song?
Why Did You Sing a Kelly Clarkson Song?:
  • Jackie Wilson - Kelly Clarkson's "Because of You": I've said this many times before, but if you're going to take on a song by a former Idol alum, you better really bring it. Jackie's version nowhere near matched up to KC's. By the way, she was cut.
Best of the Night (from clips of "Sing for your Life" Round):
  • Robbie Rosen
  • Casey Abrams
And now, after a little more than a month, we are down to our Top 24! The semifinals are next, and the power shifts from the judges to us: Next Tuesday, the Top 12 guys will perform for our vote (8-9:30pm). Wednesday will be the Top 12 girls (8-9:30pm). And Thursday will be the first live results show of the season (8-10pm - two hours? Really!?). See ya then...

Thursday, February 24, 2011

Idol-Talk: Season 10 - Vegas & Top 24 Chosen

American Idol 10: Vegas Round & Top 24 Chosen (Pt1)
Air Date: Wednesday, February 23, 2011 [8-10pm]

Source:
http://ds-this-n-that.blogspot.com/
Earlier this week, Nigel Lythgoe tweeted that they decided to cut the Vegas round down to one hour of the two hour episode, and begin the Top 24 reveal in the second hour. Initially, they had made such a big deal out of this new round where the contestants would go to Vegas and perform songs by a legendary band, but they eventually decided not to focus on it as much? I don't get it.

The remaining 61 contestants (wasn't there 60 before? How did one get added?) learned that they would be traveling to Las Vegas and perform songs (in groups of two or three) by The Beatles. They only had 24 hours to learn the song. I'm trying to figure out why they wanted them to be in duos and trios. They already did a group round back in Hollywood Week; ultimately this is an individual competition, so they should be focusing on that more. Were they trying to make sure there was drama? If so, it didn't really work out (though the same can't be said of one of the vocal coaches).

The Beatles LOVE is the current Cirque du Soleil show in Vegas, and the contestants will be performing their Beatles songs on the stage where the show is performed.

The groups had the chance to prepare with a vocal coach. And there was one in particular that really channeled Simon, but more on the Gordon Ramsay side. She was coaching Thia Megia and Melinda Ademi and yelled at them nonstop.

The saddest part of the night was finding out that many of the singers did not know any Beatles songs. Really? You've got to at least know one. I just find it hard to believe. If you want to last on this show, I hope you know a range of songs. I think back to season 9's Aaron Kelly who only performed really, really well-known songs that have been done to death before because he didn't seem to know any other songs. It reminded me of that, in a way.

The new in-house mentor Jimmy Iovine (along with some of the best music producers in the business) visits the rehearsals and provides comments and advice, even advising Lauren Alaina's group to pick a different song.

Before performing themselves, the contestants were invited to see the Cirque du Soleil show, The Beatles LOVE.

Stefano Langone & James Durbin - "Get Back": James' high notes were a lot better than last week, more in-tune.

Hayley Reinhart, Naima Adedapo, Jacob Lusk - "The Long and Winding Road": Naima was the best of the group. Jacob, on the other hand, sounded like he was gargling underwater for much of the song. But, overall, the three of them had good harmony together.

Tim Halperin, Julie Zorilla - "Something": Definitely a solid group; both were good, but Tim stood out to me as one of the best.

Kendra Chantelle, Paul McDonald - "Blackbird": This was a little strange for me. Paul's voice was a little odd. Definitely unique, but it was way too soft for me to think he has any chance in this competition.

Ashley Sullivan goes shopping for wedding attire. She and her boyfriend head over to the Little White Chapel and get married. My first thought was, she might as well have some happiness before she gets cut. When talking to Ryan Seacrest, she said she chose that chapel because Britney Spears got married there. Um, Ashley? I don't think you want to be comparing yourself to Britney when it comes to marriage.

Melinda Ademi, Thia Megia - "Here Comes the Sun": It was an okay performance; Thia's definitely the better one of the two, but I hope even she improves more, because she has a unique voice that could take her far.

Ashley Sullivan, Sophia Shorai - "We Can Work It Out": Definitely the worst performance of the night. There's no way the judges can keep Ashley in after this.

Scotty McCreary, Lauren Alaina, Denise Jackson - "Hello Goodbye": They were good together, but not individually. Even Lauren seemed a little off during that song.

Casey Abrams, Chris Medina - "Hard Days Night": What was that? It's tricky with Casey, because he can be good during some songs, but not so much during others, so he may be unpredictable in later rounds.

Robbie Rosen, Aaron Sanders, Jordan Dorsey - "Got To Get You Into My Life": One of the few standout groups who were solid together. And as always, Robbie is the standout.

Best of the Night:

  • Tim Halperin
  • Robbie Rosen
  • Naima Adedapo

Once the Top 61 are done, the judges deliberate and begin sending some through to the next round, while cutting others. I really don't know what they see in Scotty McCreary to keep him in yet again, but I predict he won't improve that much and will only show a limited range. And finally, Ashley Sullivan is eliminated! A long time coming.

The first hour concludes, and we begin the second with the opening title sequence again. The announcement of the Top 24 takes place in a hangar, set up in a dramatic fashion. When each contestant faces the judges, we are shown a montage of their journey on the show along with their final "Sing For Your Life" round that took place between Vegas and the Top 24 reveal.

The Top 24 (So Far...):

  • Naima Adedapo
  • Clint Jun Gamoa  - "Hello"
  • Hayley Reinhart
  • Paul McDonald: If I'm not mistaken, we've only seen him during this episode, so voters won't really have a whole lot to go off of when choosing who to vote for, so I don't think he'll make it past the semifinals.
  • Ashton Jones
Comments on Some of the Eliminated Singers:
  • Holly Cavanagh: Jennifer Lopez says she was in the minority among the judges and wanted her to stay in, but Steven Tyler and Randy Jackson were in the majority to cut her. It seemed like she wanted to make sure to get that out there so Holly wouldn't think of her in a negative light.
  • Deandre Brackensick: The judges gave him some really encouraging advice to keep in mind for the future.
And Finally, The Meltdown Heard 'Round the World...
Chris Medina is the final singer featured before the episode ends, and the judges end up cutting him (I think they made the right decision). Jennifer started to get emotional when trying to tell him the outcome. And when Chris leaves, she just breaks down in tears and has a meltdown. "I didn't want to tell him no." "I'm worried I didn't tell him in the right way." And finally, "I don't want to do this anymore." Steven and Randy are consoling her, and the episode ends with her not wanting to continue. We're left wondering if she won't be there tonight, and instead Steven and Randy will be the only ones there to reveal the rest of the semifinalists. I'm sure the producers just loved this moment, because they took it and just ran with it, teasing it all throughout the episode. Even if Jennifer leaves to gather herself, I don't think it will be for long; she'll just compose herself and we'll be on with the rest of the outcome.

During the auditions episodes, I was worried at first because Jennifer had a hard time saying no, but pretty soon toughened up. Now after this meltdown, I think she really needs to get it in her head that there will be tough eliminations on this show, and she needs to realize that. Even when we get to the live rounds, a deserving singer may get eliminated (which happens often on this show); she better be prepared.

Tonight, in another two hour episode (8-10pm), the judges finish revealing the Top 24 who will compete for our votes next week. Did we really need three-hours total for this reveal? Anyway, see ya then...

Saturday, February 19, 2011

Idol-Talk: Season 10 Hollywood Week - Round 3

American Idol 10: Hollywood Week - Round 3
Air Date: Thursday, February 17, 2011 [8-9pm]

Round 3: Individual Performances (with band or a capella)

Source: EW.com
 And now, the final round of Hollywood Week for season 10. After making it through the individual sudden death round, then the drama-filled group performances, the remaining 100 contestants are back to singing by themselves. But this time, they can choose to have the band accompany them (including background singers) or go it alone, a capella. And playing their own instruments is allowed as well, which I think is too early in the season to allow this. When Executive Producer and show-runner Nigel Lythgoe returned to the show this year, he said that last year the singers were hiding behind their instruments, and that he would change some things now that he's back. If he really believes that, then I don't think the singers should have this option until the live shows.

Best of the Night:

  • Thia Megia - "What A Wonderful World" (my absolute favorite song of all time!)
  • Robbie Rosen - "Gravity"
  • Sophia Shorai - "Georgia" (there were many contestants who performed this song, but Sophia outdid them all)

Good and/or Solid Performances:

  • Hailey Reinhart - "God Bless the Child"
  • Ashton Jones - "And I Am Telling You I'm Not Going" (she's definitely good, but with this song, it's virtually impossible to match up to the Jennifers that made this memorable - Holliday and Hudson)
  • Jacob Lusk - "God Bless the Child" (He's good, no doubt about that, but he wasn't as good as the judges made him out to be; there were some obvious off notes)
  • Casey Abrams - "Georgia" (played upright bass; this performance definitely stood out, but I wonder if that still would have been the case had he not used an instrument? Just a thought...)
  • Lauren Alaina - Aerosmith's "I Don't Want to Miss a Thing" (Really good, but I just wish she wouldn't have repeated her audition song.)
No:
  • Clint Jun Gamboa - "Georgia" (It seemed like he was trying to imitate Adam Lambert; very over the top on the runs and falsettos
Lyric-Forgetters:
  • Scotty McCreery & Tatynisa Wilson - They both completely forget the words and start making up their own words. This reminds me of a local radio station commercial where the people in the car are listening to a song, singing along and not saying the right lyrics.
Quit:
  • Jacqueline Dunford - She falls ill and bows out of the competition. And again, one by one the exes and the couple are departing. I think I need to put on Queen's "Another One Bites the Dust." Chelsee Oaks (part of the exes), now the remaining member of the foursome, is distraught over this news. Speaking of whom...
Bad:
  • Chelsee Oaks - Kelly Clarkson's "Because of You" (I say this all the time, but if you're going to perform a song by an Idol alum, especially one as great as KC, you better bring it. And Chelsee doesn't do the song justice.
  • Ashley Sullivan - Michael Buble's "Everything" (She dedicates the song to her boyfriend, then proceeds to fumble and asks to start over. This causes her to continue messing up and ends up ruining the whole performance. How is she still in the running again?)
After everyone performs, the judges deliberate. Everyone is split up into four groups, each going to a different room. Room 1 is still in. Room 2 is out. Room 3 is out as well, which means that room 4 is still in the competition. Chelsee Oaks (the sole member of the exes and the couple) is eliminated, finally! But how did they keep Ashley Sullivan in? She basically had a nervous breakdown on stage, which should have been the end of it, but the judges must have felt sorry for her. There's no way she can make it any farther; she has never had a good performance ever. And even though Scotty M. and Tatynisa did not know the words to their songs, they're somehow still in it as well. I don't get it.

Next Wednesday will showcase a new round of the competition, where the remaining 60 contestants head to Las Vegas to perform songs (with only 24 hours to learn them) by The Beatles. See ya then...

Thursday, February 17, 2011

Idol-Talk: Season 10 Hollywood Week - Round 2

American Idol 10: Hollywood Week - Round 2
Air Date: Wednesday, February 16, 2011 [8-10pm]

Round 2: Group Performances

Source: PremiumHollywood.com
Out of every round that occurs during Hollywood Week, the one that provides the most stress, entertainment, and drama is the Group Round. The rules: Each group must have at least three singers. And each group must have a mix of Day 1 and Day 2 contestants (Day 1 and Day 2 referring to when they performed during Round 1). After Round 1, many Day 1 contestants who had the second day off were already forming groups and practicing, thinking it would give them a head start. Little did they know the rules were a little different this year.

Right from the start, the drama that is Tiffany Rios erupted immediately when she tried to find a group to join, only to find no one wanted her. I mean, could anyone blame them (especially after what eventually happened with her performance)? At one point, Tiffany stole Jessica Yantz from a group she was already in. And she wasn't the only one: multiple groups were stealing other singers from each other, some abandoning their own groups, some having to audition to join a group. But back to Tiffany for a moment. She and Jessica could not for the life of them convince anybody else to join their group, so one of the producers allowed them to be a duo group. I don't think that producer should have allowed that; if they couldn't find a group, then they should be disqualified, because they weren't able to conform to the rules.

Another annoyance in this episode was the prevalence of the stage moms. For the singers who are underage, they have to have a parent accompany them on this journey. And with the age requirement lowered to fifteen, there seemed to be more of an abundance of parents, and as a result, stage moms. They were helping out their children. Not so much giving advice as telling them how to perform and what to do. (As an aside, do you remember season 7's behind-the-scenes stage dad, Jeff Archuleta, father of David Archuleta?)

The contestants were up pretty much all night rehearsing.

At one point, Ashley Sullivan has a sort of nervous breakdown and wants to quit. A producer talks to her and tells her to really think about this decision she wants to make. She talks to her boyfriend and eventually decides to stay. Darn! I was hoping we would have a quitter. (Maybe the high-drama was getting to me there).

Fifteen-year-old Jacee Badeaux is forced out of his group and attempts to find another group to join. Brett Loewenstern goes in search of another member because they need a Day 2 singer, and comes across Jacee, who joins their group.

I can understand now why they needed two hours for this episode. The change in the rules (needing a mix of Day 1 and Day 2 singers) caused so much drama that the show wouldn't have done it justice trying to fit both that and the singing into an hour. In fact, the actual performances didn't begin until 8:39pm.

At first, I tried to write down everybody's names and grade each group, but I found I wasn't able to enjoy the performances, so I'm just posting a select amount that I want to showcase (as I did with the auditions).

Best of the Night:
Jordan Dorsey, Robbie Rosen - Jackson 5's "I Want You Back": Robbie was the best of the group and one of my favorites of the night.

Terrible/Eliminated:
Tiffany Rios, Jessica Yantz - Beyonce's "Irreplaceable": It's a good think no one else joined their group, because they would have been toast. Jessica doomed herself by teaming with Tiffany. And Tiffany just wailed through the entire song, which hurt my ears.

One singer overslept; a producer and/or cameraman goes to his room and tells him his group is up. His group is searching all over trying to find him. In the meantime, Steven Tyler goes up on stage and plays the drums to entertain everyone until the group can get their act together.

Jovanny Barreto, Kevin Campos, Jorge Gabriele, Karen Rodriguez - "Just the Way You Are": Jovanny and Karen are still in; Karen is the best of the group.

Good:
Lauren Alaina's Group - "Some Kind of Wonderful": They bring Steven up on stage and sing to him as he sits on a chair in front of them; seeing his expressions as he's checking out the girls was hilarious.

It's a good thing Ashley Sullivan decided not to quit, because she made it to the next round. But she wasn't all that good, so I don't think she'll be around much longer.

James Durbin's Group - Queen's "Somebody to Love": James (the Adam Lambert-wannabe) is the main feature of the group. At the end, he does the signature Adam Lambert/Siobhan Magnus note, which lasts quite a long time and keeps getting higher and higher. I would be all for him doing that, except that it was terrible. He was good during his audition, but with each round, his voice is not getting any better; in fact, it's getting worse.

Best of the Night:
Stage Mom Group: Deandre Brackensick brought out a beautiful falsetto. When I say "Best of the Night," I don't mean the entire group; some were not as good as the judges made them out to be. Overall they were pretty much good, but Deandre stood out to me.

Hollie Cavanaugh's Group: Hollie was the only somewhat decent one of the group.

Best of the Night:
Da'Quela Payne, Matthew Nuss, Naima Adedapo, Jacob Lusk: I loved this group! Naima, to me, was the best, but this was such a solid group; each singer provided something great to the song.

We see a montage of Steven's one-liners.

Best of the Night:
Denise Jackson, Stevie Cain, Natalie Hanson, Brett Loewenstern, Jacee Badeaux - "Mercy": Brett was the best of the group, and continues to be one of my favorites this year. Jacee, unfortunately, was not that good this time; he got the sympathy card from the judges, who caved in and let him stay after all that he's been through with getting kicked out of a group and all that.

Best of the Night:
Monique De Los Santos, Clint Jun Gamboa: Even though Clint is the villain for kicking Jacee out of the group, he still was, along with Monique, one of the best singers.

Should Have Been Eliminated:
Chelsee Oaks, Jacqueline Dunford, Rob Bolin - "Forget You": Rob didn't know any of the words, so he sang about how he didn't know the words. Jacqueline used the explicit version of the lyrics. The judges eliminated Rob, but they should have dropped every one in the group. These girls will not last long. One by one, the exes and the couple are going.

Tonight, we're back to one hour (8-9pm) when the 100 remaining contestants will return to individual performances in the final Hollywood Week episode. See ya then...

Saturday, February 12, 2011

Opinion: Dina Lohan - Don't Take It Personally

Image Credit: zimbio.com
Last November during an episode of Glee, guest star Gwyneth Paltrow, as the substitute Spanish teacher, asked the class in Spanish, "Lindsay Lohan is totally crazy, right?" She then proceeded to teach the class about counting in Spanish: "How many times has Lindsay Lohan been to rehab?" It was obviously meant as a joke (hey, I laughed).

After the episode aired, Lindsay's mother, Dina Lohan, attacked Glee for going after her daughter, threatening to take legal action. She told Gossip Cop, "'Our lawyers are sending a letter' to 'Glee' on the grounds that the show allegedly defamed the actress who, by all accounts, is working hard on her recovery." If you've paid attention to Lindsay's actions since November, you know that she obviously hasn't been working all that hard on any sort of a recovery. I never heard any more news on that legal action, which means she had no ground to stand on.

Last month, some of the cast members ran into Lindsay and apologized. Okay - everything then seemed to be in the past and all was good in the world again...whoops, I spoke too soon...

In the recent post-Super Bowl episode of Glee, guest star Katie Couric, when interviewing Sue Sylvester, ran off a list of the Losers of the Year. Among the names on said list were Dina Lohan, and sparky Lohan, their dog. Pop Eater's Rob Shuter has a source who says, "They are all a bunch of bullies. Dina is hurt and shocked and hasn't done anything to deserve this constant teasing from this show."

Okay Dina, have you looked at yourself or your family? The only reason people know your name is because you are Lindsay's mom and manager. You rode her coattails in order to claim a piece of that fame, even going so far as exploiting the rest of your family on a short-lived reality show for your own gain. You claim you want privacy for your family, but yet you do something that this to put the spotlight on all of them.

I realize that Lindsay is 22, legally an adult (I was born on the same day and year as her, incidentally), but not only as her manager, but as her mother as well, you need to get your priorities in order here.  Even rehab experts have said you should stop being her manager and "start acting like her mom."

Who cares if Glee is taking jabs at you or your daughter? Every celebrity in the world has had some sort of criticism thrown at them. You're not the celebrity in this ordeal. So you need to not take it personally, and focus on helping your daughter instead of answering to every critic.

I would suggest staying out of the limelight for a while. That way, you can be the mother that Lindsay needs right now. She has obviously gone through some things, and especially right now continues to spiral downward. If she isn't accepting help, that's one thing (I don't know if she is or isn't). But you can't expect us to take you seriously if you always go to the media to respond to the latest attack or find a way to keep yourself in the spotlight once more.

I can understand why you would be hurt by these jokes and jabs. It's your daughter, for crying out loud (and even you). The first reaction would be to respond to it all. But it's not healthy for you or Lindsay right now to continue doing things to grab attention. Lindsay needs help, and I hope you will do what you can to help her.

I have only seen Lindsay in a couple of movies (Parent Trap being my favorite). She is a talented actress. Unfortunately, though, she has let her personal life get in the way of her becoming the giant star that she could have been. We've seen young stars go down the wrong path before (Paris Hilton, Nicole Richie, Britney Spears); even Miley Cyrus is going through one right now. If Lindsay is able to surround herself by people who can take a firm stand and not let her get away with whatever she wants, then maybe she can dust herself off and make a rise back to the top again. But until that happens, we will just continue to see the trouble in her life (the most recent one being the accusation that she stole a necklace from a store).

So Dina, do you understand why you and your daughter are always the butt of jokes? We haven't seen a positive change from either of you, that's why. I'm not here to tell you how to be a mother or how to run your life, but what I'm advising is to listen to what we're all saying so you can first try to understand why you are perceived the way you do. Then tune us all out and look at what you can do to change that perception. What you heard on Glee was just one of a million criticisms out there; don't take it personally.

America loves a comeback story, and I know we would love to see Lindsay have that. Help her have that comeback. Not as a manager, but as her mom. As a human being who cares about and wants to help someone in need.